Which one would people prefer if we signed one ?

Brian

Interesting, from a guy who seems to have contacts, both are good players but come with baggage and different skills.

Todd, is a great player but is always injured, Justin is great winger who would be very good in our side, but the players didn't want him last season, has this changed?

Can you imagine a back line of carney, griffin, fonua and talanoa







The players don;t want that one in case he starts banging their wives and the other one is made of balsa wood and earns a fortune so can't see either signing personally

Think I'd prefer Justin

Would hope Justin has learned his lesson by now but still if our current players wouldn't like it then stay well clear IMO.

Can't imagine Justin and Jordan Thompson getting on too well ....

Todd is often injured and Justin often banned.
To be honest, I wouldn't be fussed by either of them.

Hypothetically, if Todd had no injury problems I'd take him in a heartbeat.

We don't need Justin and cannot afford Todd. In fact we couldn't afford either.

I think our signings are done for next year which will do for me. 2018 will be massive from a recruitment sense as we will have a lot of cap to play with I reckon

Our rumours thread next year will break message board records.

For now though I don't want to imagine a team without all those great players.

we have no cap space so immaterial really, think there is more chance of players becoming available from relegated SL team and at the moment that could be one of three Danny Brough is the pick from the giants and not got a clue who I would want from the other 2 clubs, but I think we would have to lose someone to bring someone in and I wouldn't want to do that TBH

I wouldn't rule out Justin Carney, as this poster has a really good record of inside Info and we nearly signed him last year, he has recently signed a new deal so it may be dependent on Salford getting relegated.

Michael's has been great this year, but Carney is an upgrade on him and if the club want to sign him, you have to trust their judgement.